J441 Prompt: Over the past few weeks there has been much discussion regarding the opposition to health care reform and President Obama’s race. If Hillary Clinton were president, do you feel her gender would have an effect on support or opposition of health care reform?
Response: Yes, there has been much discussion regarding the opposition to Obama’s health care reform plan. I actually came across an article about a Facebook poll that asked if President Obama should be assassinated. It was shutdown and the Secret Service has begun investigation, and while there’s no evidence that the poll was in relation to the health care reform plan, the timing seems to elude that the two may be correlated. In any case, I would say political activism is at an all time high, especially considering that President Obama has been in office for about nine months. I don’t think I remember people having so much to say about Bush a year into his presidency. Being the first African-American president is a large source of this activism, I’m sure, but I also feel like it’s the extent to which Obama is liberal that is stirring up some controversy. Now if Hillary Clinton were to be serving in place of Obama, I honestly don’t think there would be much contrast between the two regardless of their differences in race and gender. While her being Caucasian is a common thread between her and the former 43 presidents, her being female is the new discrepancy and similarly while Obama being male is his common thread, his race is the new factor. Treating both gender and race as equal, but different factors, the equation leads to the same answer. However, to consider and weigh gender and race different values, could mean a completely different outcome. I find myself in the middle. I am not naive enough to equate both gender and race as equal, but at the same time, I don’t think they are light-years apart in the weight they hold. In the particular case of health care reform, I think more than the physical qualities of the proposer (Obama or H. Clinton), the implications of the actual reform plan is what has the public so heated up. I can imagine a similar reaction from the public if the proposer were any other former president. In the end, the people who care about the race or gender of the proposer and base their decisions solely or even heavily on those physical attributes, are insignificant in number and/or the political power they hold (under the assumption that they are not very well politically aware or knowledgeable). In short, no, I do not think that there would be a significant effect on the support or opposition towards health care reform if H. Clinton were to be president.
Recent Comments